+- The Voynich Ninja (https://www.voynich.ninja)
+-- Forum: Voynich Research (https://www.voynich.ninja/forum-27.html)
+--- Forum: Voynich Talk (https://www.voynich.ninja/forum-6.html)
+--- Thread: A name to attach to the origins of the manuscript (/thread-5302.html)
RE: A name to attach to the origins of the manuscript - Jorge_Stolfi - 27-01-2026
(27-01-2026, 01:14 AM)ReneZ wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.Then again, a non-illustrated MS on paper would still have been a lot easier to make, and a lot less expensive.
Yeah, that is a good question: why did the Author chose to put the thing to vellum?
He must have had that material on paper first, either as unorganized notes or as a more organized paper book or set of booklets. That should have been enough for his own use, if he had any.
But, a you say, he would not need the decorative illustrations, or made-up plant drawings.
My guess is that he decided to make a vellum copy in order to "monetize" those personal notes and booklets, by selling them to some curious scholar, or collector of peculiar books. I imagine that a book on vellum would fetch a much higher price than the same contents on paper. Surely more than the cost of the vellum.
That could also explain the echoes of Pharma in the Herbal. I imagine him trying to sell the book without the Herbal, but being told "You call that a herbal? This is a herbal, see: it has one plant per page, with a full drawing of the plant, and at least a long paragraph of text..." Then he going back home and starting to expand his Pharma notes into that format...
But maybe instead it was a vanity project -- he wanted to see his beloved notes set in a prestigious form, like other books that people treasured.
Or maybe he wanted to leave the book to his heirs, and thus chose vellum for its supposed durability.
All the best, --stolfi
RE: A name to attach to the origins of the manuscript - Aga Tentakulus - 27-01-2026
RE: A name to attach to the origins of the manuscript - ReneZ - 27-01-2026
RE: A name to attach to the origins of the manuscript - Aga Tentakulus - 27-01-2026
RE: A name to attach to the origins of the manuscript - Antonio García Jiménez - 27-01-2026
RE: A name to attach to the origins of the manuscript - Rafal - 27-01-2026
RE: A name to attach to the origins of the manuscript - LisaFaginDavis - 27-01-2026
RE: A name to attach to the origins of the manuscript - Rafal - 27-01-2026
RE: A name to attach to the origins of the manuscript - Mark Knowles - 27-01-2026
RE: A name to attach to the origins of the manuscript - Mark Knowles - 27-01-2026