+- The Voynich Ninja (https://www.voynich.ninja)
+-- Forum: Voynich Research (https://www.voynich.ninja/forum-27.html)
+--- Forum: Voynich Talk (https://www.voynich.ninja/forum-6.html)
+--- Thread: Solutions [discussion thread - moved] (/thread-4341.html)
RE: Solutions [discussion thread - moved] - Bluetoes101 - 10-08-2024
Here's a fictional solution I just made (below). You can phonetically-hammer (I think I just made up a term..) the first paragraph in EVA to modern English, read from end to start.
So why is it bad?
1. It can't be repeated by others. I could sit 5000 people in a room and I doubt anyone would decipher the text the same way.
2. It can't be "measured". There are no more works of this nature to substantiate my claim and my rules are unclear.
I'm sure others will find very many ways in which this is bad, but I think these two are fundamental.
Lots of stuff can "work", but if it can't be repeated by others and it can't be "measured" in some way by peers the theory is "inconsequential" to quote Einstein, or less tactfully "belongs on the trash heap" to quote Neil Degrasse Tyson. Obviously a VM solution is not a physics solution, but I think the general idea is translatable to theories. My solution can't be used, so it is inconsequential. Throws in trash heap
cfhaiin cphar cthaiin chear y dair
Certain cipher, certain cheer. You dare
okan or otaiin daiin cthar roloty oteos oteey ooiin
Open or obtain my cipher(?) relatively go in(?)
sa daraiin cthes cthoary shod ykaiin or sheky syaiir
There are within clues, theory, should you-attain or you-seek to say
dan cthar cthar are shar chtaiin kair y or ckhar sory
Then cipher, cipher is shared. Certain care or your cipher sorry
sholdy kor y cthres shory shol ataiin ar ykal fachys
You-should care your ciphers surely shall contain actual facts
RE: Solutions [discussion thread - moved] - tavie - 25-03-2025
RE: Solutions [discussion thread - moved] - Koen G - 26-03-2025
RE: Solutions [discussion thread - moved] - oshfdk - 26-03-2025
RE: Solutions [discussion thread - moved] - tavie - 30-04-2025
RE: Solutions [discussion thread - moved] - Koen G - 30-04-2025
RE: Solutions [discussion thread - moved] - Ruby Novacna - 30-04-2025
RE: Solutions [discussion thread - moved] - oshfdk - 30-04-2025
RE: Solutions [discussion thread - moved] - ReneZ - 30-04-2025
RE: Solutions [discussion thread - moved] - RobGea - 30-04-2025