+- The Voynich Ninja (https://www.voynich.ninja)
+-- Forum: Voynich Research (https://www.voynich.ninja/forum-27.html)
+--- Forum: Voynich Talk (https://www.voynich.ninja/forum-6.html)
+--- Thread: Should we have a thread to refer theorists to? (/thread-4225.html)
Should we have a thread to refer theorists to? - Koen G - 01-04-2024
It happens quite regularly that someone comes to the forum having solved the manuscript. It's always in a different way, yet always kind of in the same way as well.
And then we go through the motions of explaining them about confirmation bias and one way ciphers and why Google translate is no good and that Latin actually has grammar beyond dictionary forms and that translations should be repeatable and so on.
Might it be useful if we had a thread with all these points, so we could refer people to section 2.4 of the "So you solved the Voynich manuscript" thread?
My perhaps naive hope is that if we show that we actually predict their methods because we have seen them so many times before, maybe they will understand more quickly?
Or do you think a thread like this would be a waste of time and have no effect at all on the mind still high on the sword in the stone syndrome?
RE: Should we have a thread to refer theorists to? - pjburkshire - 01-04-2024
RE: Should we have a thread to refer theorists to? - Emma May Smith - 01-04-2024
RE: Should we have a thread to refer theorists to? - RobGea - 01-04-2024
RE: Should we have a thread to refer theorists to? - pjburkshire - 01-04-2024
RE: Should we have a thread to refer theorists to? - Koen G - 01-04-2024
RE: Should we have a thread to refer theorists to? - ReneZ - 02-04-2024
RE: Should we have a thread to refer theorists to? - bi3mw - 02-04-2024
RE: Should we have a thread to refer theorists to? - MarcoP - 02-04-2024
RE: Should we have a thread to refer theorists to? - Koen G - 02-04-2024