The Voynich Ninja
f57v – Are the empty rings really empty? - Printable Version

+- The Voynich Ninja (https://www.voynich.ninja)
+-- Forum: Voynich Research (https://www.voynich.ninja/forum-27.html)
+--- Forum: Physical material (https://www.voynich.ninja/forum-42.html)
+--- Thread: f57v – Are the empty rings really empty? (/thread-6313.html)



f57v – Are the empty rings really empty? - todihk - 18-11-2026

Hello everyone,

For a long time, I have been wondering why there are “empty” rings within the circular diagram on f57v. I have often thought about Stolfi's observations that glyphs were retraced and that the final stroke of the “y” appears smudged in the empty area.

I have also asked myself what the motivation might have been for leaving these rings empty. Was it for visual separation? Was it to allow movable discs to be placed on top? Or was there another reason?

None of these possibilities has satisfied me. Considering that the rings contain an extensive inventory of Voynich glyphs, I would actually like them to represent a “construction wheel” or even a “cipher wheel.” Of course, who wouldn't wish for that?

However, after spending a long time examining the empty rings, I noticed something. The rings do not appear to be (or to have been) quite so empty. Even at normal zoom levels, some lightened areas resembling letters can be observed.

My initial assumption was that my eyes were playing tricks on me.

But then I discovered further areas that caught my attention. I therefore had the images digitally processed using AI in several different ways (see the Filter Settings TXT file).

Upon closer examination, I noticed numerous areas that seemingly make various letters or symbols “visible” (provided that image noise and the natural pigmentation of the calfskin can be ruled out). I initially circled the suspected areas in red. However, I subsequently noticed additional areas. I have not marked all of them.

What immediately struck me was that, with the exception of one area (Image 30 – possible scratch marks?), I could not identify any traces of scraping, scratches or abrasion, such as those caused by pumice stone. There should therefore be visible traces of damage to the pigmentation within the rings.

These are not apparent. And honestly, I believe that scraping with a knife within circular rings, or carefully erasing writing with pumice stone, would be difficult for the person performing the task if they wanted to avoid damaging the remaining rings.

So the question was: are scraping and abrasion really the only options? Surprisingly, no.

It does not necessarily have to be either scraping or abrasion. A much more plausible explanation, also considering the partially missing circular lines, would be the removal of writing using liquids. There are scientific studies on this subject, as well as historical examples from the possible period of the VMS's creation:

Artificially created palimpsest using lemon juice:

University of Paderborn, in collaboration with the DESY research centre.

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

Particularly from pages 73 and 85 onwards.

Patricia Engel, on how various liquids could be used for treatment:

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

(Page 40, Table 3 = milk; page 41, Table 4 = alum and orange juice; page 42 = orange juice and other mixtures.)

Historical examples:

Biblioteca Casanatense, MS 1793 – 1422 – Recipe 42 describes the removal of writing using lemon and/or orange juice.

BnF Latin 6741 – Giovanni Alcherio wrote the original between 1382 and 1411 (expanded around 1410 in Bologna and Venice, having previously been compiled in Paris). The Latin 6741 copy was produced by Jean Le Bègue in 1431.

Recipe 2 describes the use of saltpetre and vitriol, recipe 27 describes the use of orange juice to remove writing from parchment, and recipe 34 describes the use of alum and orange juice BUT on paper.


Now I would like to return to Stolfi's observations. If I understood correctly, he himself regretted that no multispectral images of You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. had been taken. I can only agree with him!

If my eyes are not deceiving me and there really is writing within the “empty” rings, then You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. absolutely needs to be re-examined.

Furthermore, it should be investigated whether this might also be the case on other pages. If this turns out to be true, previously unknown information could potentially become visible to us.

In my opinion, You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. should therefore be examined as thoroughly as possible using the following methods:
- MSI (multispectral imaging)
- Raking-light microscopy
- FTIR (Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy;non-contact reflectance)
- MA-XRF (macro X-ray fluorescence)


Why these methods?

None of them requires material sampling, meaning that they are non-contact methods. They partly overlap in their ability to detect traces of erasure using lemon juice, orange juice, milk and alum. Different methods could therefore confirm each other's findings or individually produce better results.

A particular feature of raking-light microscopy is that it primarily reveals traces of physical alterations. This concerns, for example, Image 30, which shows a possible scratch mark. Very fine scraping would also be conceivable, but this does not rule out additional erasure using liquids.

I am aware that some of these methods require specialised equipment and are very expensive.

However, XRF analysis is particularly promising, as the University of Paderborn and DESY (see the PDF link above) have successfully employed this very method.

IMPORTANT: The image quality of some attachments is limited due to file size. In particular, the following four images may have been affected by the conversion from HEIC to JPG. I would be happy to provide higher-quality images or make them accessible via Google Drive.

A more detailed investigation of what might have shown through from the reverse side of You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. is also still required.


Fullres image of edited page: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

Complete PDF inlcuding single stats: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.
(hope it works)

Some parts need to be seen with the different filter settings.


RE: f57v – Are the empty rings really empty? - eggyk - 18-11-2026

Register or login to view the content



RE: f57v – Are the empty rings really empty? - todihk - 18-11-2026

Register or login to view the content



RE: f57v – Are the empty rings really empty? - eggyk - 18-11-2026

Register or login to view the content



RE: f57v – Are the empty rings really empty? - todihk - 18-11-2026

Register or login to view the content