06-02-2017, 10:46 AM
ReneZ,
I see that, but then he uses the same principle to claim other translations of words in the text (not labels) like Centaurea.
Is the claim then that simple substitution and Latin is only used in words that contain "taur"? It seems to me that the shots get longer and longer the more we follow up on this.
I should add that despite this, I applaud Stephen's efforts and the great website that he runs... I don't want to come across as having some personal vendetta against him! I can see the appeal of Taurus for the label, but it doesn't hold up to scrutiny in my opinion.
I see that, but then he uses the same principle to claim other translations of words in the text (not labels) like Centaurea.
Is the claim then that simple substitution and Latin is only used in words that contain "taur"? It seems to me that the shots get longer and longer the more we follow up on this.
I should add that despite this, I applaud Stephen's efforts and the great website that he runs... I don't want to come across as having some personal vendetta against him! I can see the appeal of Taurus for the label, but it doesn't hold up to scrutiny in my opinion.
![[+]](https://www.voynich.ninja/images/collapse_collapsed.png)
