9 hours ago
Title: Thought experiment: where would you put Q14 and Q8? (newcomer’s question)
I don’t want to challenge the established findings on the order of the manuscript, and I’m a newcomer here, so please take this as a pure thought experiment.
Imagine you received a box of loose, unnumbered Voynich quires, ready for binding. You can’t read the text. How would you arrange them? I would go by content and a bit of imagination, and I would arrange them slightly differently.
My proposal: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. stays the first page, and the book runs as it does now up to f116v, except that Q14 and Q8 are taken out of their current places and moved to the end:
Q1 → Q2–Q7 → Q9–Q13 → Q15–Q20 (ending f116v) → Q14 → Q8
What changes:
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. becomes an introduction. Its four paragraphs could figuratively correspond to the four content blocks that follow: botanical, astronomical, technological, and recipes.
Q14 as an interlude. It doesn’t fit any of the four themes, so it works as a separator before the final part.
Q8 as an “update”. It touches all four themes again [please see folios: ...]. My explanation is the time of writing: the project probably developed from preparation to the actual writing, so Q8 would be a small step forward, a kind of update to the original plan, written later and placed last.
My question: what evidence speaks against this (quire signatures, bifolio structure, binding traces, ink, hands, Currier A/B)? And has anyone proposed something similar?
I don’t want to challenge the established findings on the order of the manuscript, and I’m a newcomer here, so please take this as a pure thought experiment.
Imagine you received a box of loose, unnumbered Voynich quires, ready for binding. You can’t read the text. How would you arrange them? I would go by content and a bit of imagination, and I would arrange them slightly differently.
My proposal: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. stays the first page, and the book runs as it does now up to f116v, except that Q14 and Q8 are taken out of their current places and moved to the end:
Q1 → Q2–Q7 → Q9–Q13 → Q15–Q20 (ending f116v) → Q14 → Q8
What changes:
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. becomes an introduction. Its four paragraphs could figuratively correspond to the four content blocks that follow: botanical, astronomical, technological, and recipes.
Q14 as an interlude. It doesn’t fit any of the four themes, so it works as a separator before the final part.
Q8 as an “update”. It touches all four themes again [please see folios: ...]. My explanation is the time of writing: the project probably developed from preparation to the actual writing, so Q8 would be a small step forward, a kind of update to the original plan, written later and placed last.
My question: what evidence speaks against this (quire signatures, bifolio structure, binding traces, ink, hands, Currier A/B)? And has anyone proposed something similar?


![[+]](https://www.voynich.ninja/images/collapse_collapsed.png)

