18-06-2020, 05:51 AM
I'm skeptical of this solution. It plays fast and loose with the vowels and gutturals. Sometimes the script encodes א, sometimes it doesn't. In one case he converts א to ה to get the word he wants. These are different consonants. These changes seem arbitrary.
I'm also suspicious because the solution does not present a continuous Hebrew text that can be read or checked whether the result makes any grammatical sense. Hebrew makes its inflections through prefixes, suffixes, and vowel ablaut: that would seal the deal if those can be identified (particularly since some of his translations are in the present tense), but I can't find anything about them.
Furthermore, Hebrew hardly repeats words and similarly spelled words to the extent as the VM.
I'm also suspicious because the solution does not present a continuous Hebrew text that can be read or checked whether the result makes any grammatical sense. Hebrew makes its inflections through prefixes, suffixes, and vowel ablaut: that would seal the deal if those can be identified (particularly since some of his translations are in the present tense), but I can't find anything about them.
Furthermore, Hebrew hardly repeats words and similarly spelled words to the extent as the VM.
![[+]](https://www.voynich.ninja/images/collapse_collapsed.png)