Today, 04:24 AM
(This post was last modified: Today, 04:26 AM by Jorge_Stolfi.)
(Yesterday, 04:36 PM)npcompl33t wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.I’m assuming she was referring to 1 and 4.The problem is that 4 is in the wrong position for a sewing hole. And it also looks like the result of the vertical fold crossing a crease.
That fold sticks out of the stack of folios when the book it is closed. Uneven pressure on that exposed fold (like from handling the closed book) could explain those horizontal creases. I think that repeated bending of the horizontal and vertical folds eventually tore the velum creating hole 4.
Quote:What then do you think about her observation of the quire number appearing at the bottom of 67r1, that does indeed seem to indicate some sort of mismatchThe quire numbers must have been written after the bifolios were nested into quires, before the book was bound. Their only purpose was to tell the binder how the quires should be stacked. They would be useless after the book was bound.
Thus the anomalous position of the quire number on f67r1 cannot be explained by assuming that the (singulion) quire 9 was at some time bound along the fold between f67r1 and f67r2.
However, that fold is where I think that the bifolio should have been bound.
My guess is that, before the binding, bifolio f67+f68 was folded like this
I don't know how exactly f68 was folded; the drawing is just one of several possibilities. The important point is that the two flaps that are currently f67.1 and f67.2 were folded around f68.
Naturally there were no folio numbers written anywhere. The Author's intended reading order was f67r2 (flip folio) f67v2, (unfold the rest of the bifolio) f67v1, f68r1, f68r2, f68r3, (flip big folio) f68v3, f68v2, f68v1, f67r1. Note that f67r1 was meant to be the last page of that bifolio. The intended first page of that bifolio was f68r2, which by coincidence (?) is the only one with red writing.
Much later, when the owner decided to bind the book, the bifolios were nested into quires, which generally messed up their reading order. However, on that occasion it was decided that f67+f68 would be a quire by itself, accidentally with the correct reading order (f68r2 first, f67r1 last) and the quire number Q6 was written at the proper position: on the last page, namely f67r1.
However, when the binder looked at the folded bifolio with f67r1 facing up, he saw folds on both edges of it:
Then he got confused and thought that f67r1 was meant to be the first page of that quire -- and sewed it along the left edge of that page (purple)
Makes sense?
All the best, --stolfi

