The following warnings occurred:
Warning [2] Undefined variable $can_link - Line: 6 - File: showthread.php(1658) : eval()'d code PHP 8.5.12 (Linux)
File Line Function
/inc/class_error.php 157 errorHandler->error
/showthread.php(1658) : eval()'d code 6 errorHandler->error_callback
/showthread.php 1658 eval




Just a thought regarding discrepancies
#15
(2 hours ago)Jorge_Stolfi wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.
(Yesterday, 05:42 PM)Brouk Pytlík wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.I concede that this might have been prepared for a different binding, though I am not entirely certain—why, then, are only 20 of these quire marks available for the new binding? And why were the original “Q” marks not used? As for the original marks, why are they not uniform (some feature “q,” others “m,” and still others “n”)?
The quire marks re all common Latin abbreviations.  A superscript 9 means "-us". A "p" with a hook above ("ƥ") means "pr".  The variations are due to Latin spelling of the ordinal numbers:

1 - "primus" = ƥ⁹
2 - "secundus"  = 2⁹
3 - "tertius" = 3⁹
4 - "quartus" = 4t⁹  (the "t" is superscript too)
5 - "quintus" = 5t⁹  (ditto)
6 - "sextus" = 6t⁹  (ditto)
7 - septimus = 7m⁹ (the "m" is superscript too)
8 - "octavus" = "octauus" = 8u⁹ (the "u" is superscript too)
9 - "nonus" = 9n⁹ (the "n" is superscript too)
10 - "decimus" = 10m⁹ (the "m" is superscript too)
11 - "decimums primus" = 11m⁹ (the "m" is superscript too)
etc
20 - "vigesimus" = 10m⁹

The shapes of the digits 4, 5, and 7 are typical of a certain epoch which I forgot.

Quote:And which quire marks, then, belong to the original binding?

It seems consensus now that the VMS was created as a stack of loose bifolios, folded but not nested.  

According to that scenario,  a later owner (possibly 1-2 centuries later) decided to have those loose bifolios bound into a book.  He nested the bifolios into quires in a somewhat haphazard manner, so that the original reading order got completely scrambled (except in the Zodiac section, where the reading order was visible, and which was bound as isolated bifolios).  He then wrote the quire marks to tell the binder the order of the quires.  

Chemical analysis showed that the ink of the quire marks is different from all other inks in the book.  

All the best, --stolfi

I appreciate you pausing to consider this, but I must respectfully disagree with the way that statement is phrased. My hypothesis is that the sheets lay separately—for a long time, in one or more storage locations—before they were bound together. They were only bound at a point in time when people no longer knew how to read them. This aligns with my suggestion that a different arrangement would make more logical sense—though, admittedly, there is no other evidence to confirm this. On the other hand, the fact that there are four mutually corresponding sections suggests that a significant amount of preparatory work must have gone into the materials; the clean script, largely free of corrections, also points to this. Furthermore, if the original intention had simply been to create a single bifolium, it would not have been structured as four separate sections; everything would have been contained within one bifolium. Therefore, I do not believe the original concept was limited to just a single bifolium.

I suspect, however, that the reason for the time gap between the writing and the binding might be more prosaic: the Hussite unrest of that period. Europe was not a peaceful place at the time.
Reply


Messages In This Thread
RE: Just a thought regarding discrepancies - by Brouk Pytlík - 25 minutes ago

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: yinyang2024, 2 Guest(s)